A) SkyTran Instead of Light Rail
This first example compares the
28 mile long, light-rail system recently proposed for Orange County,
California to the SkyTran system. (This proposed Urban rail project
would run between the InterModal Transportation Centers in the
cities of Fullerton and Irvine and is intended to carry 60,000
passengers per day.)
|
Surface
Light Rail |
Elevated
Light Rail |
SkyTran
w/stations every half mile |
Top
Speed |
55 mph |
55 mph |
103 mph |
Average
travel speed due to stops at stations |
17
mph |
22
mph |
100
mph (only stops at your destination!) |
Time
to travel 10 miles |
35.3
minutes |
27
minutes |
6
minutes |
Time
to travel 28 miles |
1 Hr 39
min |
1 Hr 16
min |
16.8
minutes |
System
Installation Costs |
$1.3
billion |
$1.8
billion |
$0.055
billion |
%
of Light Rail Cost |
72% |
100
% |
3% |
Hourly
passenger capacity |
15,000 |
15,000 |
40,320
(80,640 if two persons per vehicle) |
Annual
gross to County based on 60,000 per day usage |
$43.8
million |
$43.8
million |
$43.8
million |
Annual
operating Expenses |
Assume
$0* |
Assume
$0* |
$12.6
million |
Excess
remaining after expenses |
Same $43.8
million |
Same $43.8
million |
$31.2
Million |
Annual
return to County for its transportation investment |
3.3%* |
2.4%* |
56.8% |
*Annual
expenses for energy, maintenance, operations,
salaries of operators, facilities, etc. of light
rail typically exceed the annual income from
fare revenue. Obviously, even with zero
expense the annual return to the County is
awful. As a good example, the Orange County
BUS system currently has a budget of $122 million
and only brings in fare revenues of $31.7 million
(just 26% of costs is recovered). Surface
light rail also means big $ for law suits every time
a pedestrian is run over and killed.
Source: Orange County Register, September
13, 1998: "Urban Rail Project Chugging
Ahead." |
Also Consider a Choice
for Minimum Visual Pollution
Light rail cars use
overhead contact wires to obtain electric power. These continuous
power lines may be as high as 25 feet above the street.
Futuristic SkyTran vehicles operate at 20 feet in the air without
the visual pollution of ugly tracks and vehicles on the ground
itself. Don’t forget that with SkyTran there also is no need
to buy and clear (destroy) 100 foot wide swaths of existing
commercial buildings, homes and schools to install light rail tracks
and stations.
|